Self Deport Statistics in US 2025 | Key Facts

Self Deport Statistics in US

Self Deportation Process in US 2025

The self-deportation process in the US represents a significant shift in immigration enforcement strategy, allowing individuals without legal status to voluntarily return to their home countries rather than face formal removal proceedings. Under the current administration’s policy framework, this process has been streamlined through the CBP Home mobile application, which was launched in March 2025 as a rebranded version of the previous CBP One platform. The program offers financial incentives and travel assistance to encourage voluntary departures, positioning itself as a more cost-effective alternative to traditional detention and deportation procedures.

This voluntary departure mechanism differs fundamentally from formal deportation orders issued by immigration judges. While traditional deportations result in permanent immigration records that typically impose 5 to 10-year reentry bans or even permanent inadmissibility, voluntary departure through official channels allows participants to potentially preserve their future immigration options. The Department of Homeland Security has estimated that processing voluntary departures costs approximately 70 percent less than conducting arrests, detention, and formal removals, making it an economically attractive option for federal enforcement agencies seeking to manage limited resources while pursuing immigration enforcement goals.

Key Self Deportation Facts and Statistics in the US 2025

Fact Category Verified Data Source
Total Formal ICE Deportations (FY 2024) 271,484 individuals ICE Annual Report FY 2024
Deportation Increase (FY 2023 to FY 2024) 90.4% increase ICE Annual Report FY 2024
Average Daily ICE Arrests (FY 2024) 310 arrests per day ICE Enforcement Statistics
Criminal Arrests as Percentage (FY 2024) 71.7% (81,312 out of 113,431) ICE Annual Report FY 2024
Average Cost Per Traditional Deportation $17,121 DHS Official Statement (May 2025)
Estimated Cost Savings (Voluntary Departure) 70% reduction DHS Official Statement (May 2025)
CBP Home App Launch Date March 10, 2025 DHS Press Release
CBP Home App Registrations (Early April 2025) Approximately 2,500 people Independent Media Reports
Exit Bonus Stipend (Initial) $1,000 DHS Official Statement (May 2025)
Exit Bonus Stipend (Holiday 2025) $3,000 (through Dec 31) DHS Press Release (December 2025)
ICE Detention Population (End of FY 2024) 37,684 individuals ICE Annual Report FY 2024
Non-Detained Docket Size (End of FY 2024) 7.6 million cases ICE Annual Report FY 2024

Data Source: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Annual Reports, Department of Homeland Security Official Statements, and Federal Immigration Statistics

The data presented in this table represents the most recent verified statistics from official U.S. government sources regarding immigration enforcement and voluntary departure programs. The 271,484 formal deportations recorded in Fiscal Year 2024 marked the highest removal total since 2015, representing a dramatic escalation in enforcement activity compared to previous years. This 90.4 percent increase from FY 2023 reflects enhanced operational capacity, expanded international cooperation for deportation flights, and policy changes that prioritized rapid processing of recent border arrivals alongside individuals with criminal histories.

The cost differential between traditional deportation and voluntary departure programs remains substantial, with the average traditional removal costing taxpayers $17,121 per individual when accounting for arrest operations, detention expenses, legal proceedings, and transportation. In contrast, the CBP Home voluntary departure program was designed to reduce these expenses by approximately 70 percent by eliminating arrest and detention costs while still ensuring monitored departures. The initial financial incentive of $1,000 was subsequently tripled to $3,000 for the 2025 holiday period to accelerate voluntary departures and reduce the burden on detention facilities, which housed 37,684 individuals at the conclusion of Fiscal Year 2024. These statistics illustrate the government’s dual approach of aggressive enforcement combined with incentivized voluntary compliance.

ICE Formal Deportations and Removals in the US 2024-2025

Fiscal Year Total ICE Deportations Percentage Change Criminal Deportations Average Daily Arrests
FY 2022 72,000 Baseline Data Not Specified Data Not Specified
FY 2023 143,000 +98.6% from FY 2022 73,822 (43% of arrests) Data Not Specified
FY 2024 271,484 +90.4% from FY 2023 81,312 (71.7% of arrests) 310 per day
FY 2025 (Partial) 605,000+ (through Dec 2025) Projected Record Prioritized Criminal Focus 824 per day (Jan-Oct 2025)

Data Source: ICE Annual Reports FY 2023-2024, DHS Press Releases, CBS News Internal Government Figures

The escalation in formal ICE deportations over the past three fiscal years demonstrates unprecedented enforcement intensity. From a baseline of 72,000 deportations in FY 2022, the numbers more than doubled to 143,000 in FY 2023 as the Biden administration responded to record border crossing numbers and ended Title 42 public health expulsions. The trend continued dramatically in FY 2024 with 271,484 deportations, marking the highest removal total in a decade and surpassing previous peaks from the first Trump administration.

The composition of enforcement actions has shifted significantly, with criminal arrests comprising 71.7 percent of all ICE arrests in FY 2024 compared to just 43 percent in FY 2023. This represents a strategic reorientation toward individuals with criminal convictions or pending charges, even as total arrest numbers decreased from 170,590 in FY 2023 to 113,431 in FY 2024. The average daily arrest rate of 310 individuals in FY 2024 increased substantially to 824 arrests per day during the first ten months of 2025 under the current administration, reflecting expanded enforcement operations and the involvement of additional federal agencies. By December 2025, the administration had announced over 605,000 total deportations for the calendar year, positioning 2025 as potentially the highest removal year on record.

Voluntary Departure Program Statistics in the US 2025

Program Metric Verified Data Timeframe Status
CBP Home App Launch March 10, 2025 Single Date Official Launch
Registered Users (Early Period) Approximately 2,500 Through April 2025 Independently Reported
DHS Claimed “Tens of Thousands” Using App No Exact Figure Provided Through December 2025 Not Independently Verified
Financial Incentive (Initial) $1,000 exit bonus May 2025 – December 2025 Active Program
Financial Incentive (Holiday Period) $3,000 exit bonus Through December 31, 2025 Limited Time Offer
Free Airfare Government-funded travel May 2025 – Present Active Benefit
Civil Fine Forgiveness Waiver of departure penalties May 2025 – Present Active Benefit
Estimated Cost Savings vs Traditional 70% reduction Per DHS Statement Program Justification

Data Source: DHS Official Statements, CBP Home Website, Independent Media Verification Reports

The CBP Home voluntary departure program was officially launched on March 10, 2025, as a digital platform allowing individuals without legal immigration status to self-report their intention to leave the United States. According to independently verified reports from April 2025, approximately 2,500 people had registered through the application during its initial operational period. The Department of Homeland Security subsequently claimed that “tens of thousands” had utilized the program by December 2025, though this figure has not been independently verified by external agencies or media organizations, and DHS has declined to release detailed enrollment statistics or documentation showing precise usage numbers.

The program’s incentive structure evolved throughout 2025 to encourage greater participation. Initially offering a $1,000 exit bonus along with government-funded airfare and forgiveness of civil fines for immigration violations, the Department of Homeland Security increased the financial incentive to $3,000 for individuals who register and depart by December 31, 2025. This holiday-period enhancement was explicitly designed to accelerate voluntary departures and reduce detention facility populations during the year-end period. The program promises participants that they will be “deprioritized” for ICE enforcement actions while demonstrating “meaningful strides” toward departure, though specific guidelines defining this protection period remain unpublished. The 70 percent cost reduction compared to traditional arrest-detention-removal operations provides the primary fiscal justification for the program, with DHS calculating that voluntary departures substantially decrease operational expenses.

DHS Self-Deportation Claims vs Verified Data in the US 2025

Category DHS Official Claims Independently Verified Data Verification Status
Total “Self-Deportations” Since January 2025 1.9 million individuals Not independently confirmed Disputed by Experts
Total Formal ICE Deportations (Jan-Dec 2025) 605,000+ individuals 605,000 confirmed Verified by Multiple Sources
CBP Home App Users “Tens of thousands” 2,500 (April), no verified update Exact numbers not released
Internal Government Data (Jan-June 2025) Claimed 1.6M self-deported 13,000 via official channels CBS News Internal Figures
Total Departures (Combined Claim) 2.5 million by December 2025 Only formal removals verified Verification not possible

Data Source: DHS Press Releases, CBS News Internal Government Documents, Immigration Policy Expert Analysis

A substantial discrepancy exists between the Department of Homeland Security’s public claims regarding self-deportation numbers and independently verified data from government sources. DHS has consistently claimed that 1.9 million individuals voluntarily self-deported since January 2025, with Secretary Kristi Noem stating in December 2025 that combined with formal deportations, over 2.5 million people had left the United States during the year. However, these figures face significant credibility challenges from immigration researchers and investigative journalists who have obtained internal government data contradicting the official narrative.

According to internal government figures obtained by CBS News, during the first six months of the Trump administration’s second term, the government formally deported approximately 150,000 individuals while recording only 13,000 self-deportations through official tracking mechanisms. This represents a dramatic disparity from the 1.6 million self-deportations claimed by DHS for roughly the same period. Immigration policy experts have noted that the 1.9 million figure appears to be derived from Current Population Survey data showing declines in the foreign-born population, which the Census Bureau itself warns against using for precise immigration estimates due to methodology limitations. The DHS has declined to provide detailed breakdowns showing how many individuals received government-funded travel assistance versus those who departed independently, how verification of departures was conducted, or what methodology was used to calculate the self-deportation totals, making independent verification impossible.

Cost Analysis of Deportation vs Voluntary Departure in the US 2025

Cost Category Traditional ICE Deportation CBP Home Voluntary Departure Cost Savings
Average Total Cost Per Person $17,121 Approximately $5,136 70% reduction
Arrest Operations Included Eliminated Significant savings
Detention Costs (Adult) $165 per day Eliminated Varies by detention length
Detention Costs (Family) $296 per day Eliminated Varies by detention length
Legal Processing Immigration court proceedings Voluntary waiver Court system relief
Transportation Government charter flights Commercial airfare Reduced per-person cost
Financial Incentive None $1,000-$3,000 exit bonus Added program cost
Estimated Annual Traditional Costs (271K deportations) $4.64 billion N/A Based on FY 2024 data

Data Source: DHS Official Statements, ICE Budget Documents, Independent Cost Analysis Studies

The financial comparison between traditional deportation and voluntary departure reveals substantial cost differentials that justify the incentive-based program from a fiscal perspective. The $17,121 average cost for traditional ICE deportations encompasses multiple operational components: field operations for locating and arresting individuals, detention facility expenses averaging $165 per day for adults and $296 per day for families, immigration court proceedings including legal representation and judicial resources, and transportation via government charter flights that can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars for certain international destinations. For the 271,484 deportations conducted in Fiscal Year 2024, this equates to approximately $4.64 billion in total enforcement costs.

In contrast, the CBP Home voluntary departure program eliminates arrest and detention expenses while substituting commercial airfare and the exit bonus payment. Even with the enhanced $3,000 holiday incentive, DHS calculates the per-person cost at approximately $5,136, representing the claimed 70 percent reduction in overall expenses. This cost structure makes voluntary departure economically attractive for managing large-scale removals without proportionally expanding detention infrastructure or enforcement personnel. However, critics note that the effectiveness of this cost-saving strategy depends entirely on actual participation rates, and with only 2,500 verified registrations by April 2025 against claims of millions of self-deportations, the true cost-effectiveness remains difficult to assess. The program’s success in generating genuine voluntary departures versus simply counting population fluctuations will ultimately determine whether taxpayers realize the projected savings.

ICE Detention and Enforcement Operations in the US 2024-2025

Operational Metric FY 2024 Data FY 2025 Data (Partial) Change
Total ICE Arrests 113,431 595,000+ (Jan-Dec 2025) 424% increase
Criminal Arrests 81,312 (71.7% of total) Prioritized enforcement focus Percentage data pending
Average Daily Arrests (FY 2024) 310 per day 824 per day (Jan-Oct 2025) 166% increase
Detention Population (End of Period) 37,684 detained 65,000+ detained (June 2025) 72% increase
Immigration Detainers Issued 149,764 Data not yet released N/A
Non-Detained Docket Cases 7.6 million Estimated continued growth Growing backlog
Average Length of Detention Varies significantly Varies significantly Case-dependent

Data Source: ICE Annual Reports, TRAC Immigration Data, DHS Enforcement Statistics

The intensity of ICE enforcement operations increased dramatically between Fiscal Year 2024 and 2025. While FY 2024 recorded 113,431 total arrests, the first eleven months of 2025 saw over 595,000 arrests, representing a more than fourfold increase in enforcement activity. The average daily arrest rate climbed from 310 individuals in FY 2024 to 824 per day during the January through October 2025 period, reflecting expanded operational capacity and the involvement of additional federal law enforcement agencies including the FBI, U.S. Marshals Service, and Drug Enforcement Administration in supporting immigration enforcement missions.

The detention population grew correspondingly, from 37,684 individuals at the end of Fiscal Year 2024 to over 65,000 by mid-2025, with the administration announcing plans to expand capacity to 100,000 detention beds. The number of immigration detainers issued to local law enforcement agencies reached 149,764 in FY 2024, representing a 19.5 percent increase from the previous year and reflecting enhanced cooperation between federal immigration authorities and state and local police departments. Despite this aggressive enforcement posture, the non-detained docket continued to expand, reaching 7.6 million pending cases by the end of FY 2024, as the immigration court system struggled to process cases faster than new ones entered the system. The 71.7 percent of arrests involving individuals with criminal convictions or pending charges in FY 2024 represented a strategic focus on public safety priorities, though by 2025, arrests increasingly included individuals without criminal records as enforcement expanded beyond this targeted approach.

Country of Origin Breakdown for Deportations in the US 2024-2025

Country Total ICE Arrests (FY 2024) Percentage of Total Notable Trends
Mexico 69,364 25.0% Largest single nationality
Guatemala 36,104 13.0% Northern Triangle priority
Honduras 27,978 10.1% Northern Triangle priority
Ecuador 22,936 8.3% Significant increase from previous years
Colombia 20,123 7.3% South American priority
El Salvador 24,000 (approximate) 8.7% Northern Triangle priority
Venezuela Significant numbers Data not specified Third-country removal agreements
Other Countries 70,979 25.6% 185+ additional nations
Total All Countries 277,686 arrests 100% 192 destination countries

Data Source: ICE Enforcement Statistics, Newsweek Data Analysis, ICE Annual Report FY 2024

The nationality composition of ICE enforcement actions in Fiscal Year 2024 reflected both traditional migration patterns and emerging trends in unauthorized immigration. Mexican nationals continued to represent the largest single group with 69,364 arrests, accounting for 25 percent of all enforcement actions. The Northern Triangle countries of Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador collectively represented approximately 32 percent of arrests, with 36,104, 27,978, and 24,000 arrests respectively, reflecting continued high migration pressure from Central America driven by violence, economic instability, and natural disasters.

Notably, Ecuador and Colombia emerged as significant source countries with 22,936 and 20,123 arrests respectively, representing a dramatic increase from previous years as South American migration routes expanded. Venezuelan nationals also featured prominently in enforcement statistics, though exact figures were not separately reported in available data. The Trump administration negotiated third-country removal agreements allowing some Venezuelan nationals to be deported to El Salvador or Panama rather than directly to Venezuela, whose government has periodically refused to accept deportation flights. Overall, ICE conducted removals to 192 different countries in FY 2024, including charter flights to distant destinations in Africa and Asia, with some individual flights costing up to $300,000 depending on the destination and number of passengers. The diversity of source countries reflects the increasingly global nature of unauthorized immigration to the United States beyond traditional Mexico-Central America patterns.

Voluntary Departure vs Formal Deportation: Legal Consequences in the US 2025

Consequence Category Voluntary Departure Formal Deportation/Removal Order
Immigration Record No formal removal order Permanent removal order on record
Reentry Ban Duration Potentially no ban if timely departure Typically 5-10 years, possibly permanent
Unlawful Presence Bars 3-year bar (6-12 months present) 10-year bar (1+ year unlawfully present)
Future Visa Applications May not automatically disqualify Significant negative impact
Criminal Reentry Penalties Standard illegal reentry charges Up to 20 years federal prison
Compliance Requirements Must depart within specified timeframe Government arranges forced removal
Financial Responsibility Traditionally self-funded (or CBP Home incentive) Government funds removal
Eligibility for Future Relief Generally preserved May be barred from certain relief forms
Civil Fines for Non-Compliance Up to $1,000 plus 10-year relief ban Additional penalties may apply

Data Source: Immigration and Nationality Act, ICE Policy Documents, DHS CBP Home Program Guidelines

The legal consequences of voluntary departure versus formal deportation differ substantially in ways that significantly impact future immigration options. Individuals granted voluntary departure by an immigration judge or ICE do not receive a formal removal order, which means they avoid the most severe reentry restrictions that accompany deportation. However, voluntary departure requires strict compliance with departure deadlines, typically 60 to 120 days, and failure to depart results in civil fines up to $1,000 plus a 10-year ban on most forms of immigration relief. When properly completed, voluntary departure can preserve eligibility for future visa applications, though prior unlawful presence still triggers reentry bars of 3 years for 6-12 months unlawfully present or 10 years for more than one year unlawfully present.

In contrast, formal deportation with a removal order creates a permanent immigration violation record that typically imposes a minimum 5-year reentry ban, with 10-year or permanent bans common depending on the circumstances. Individuals removed for criminal convictions, immigration fraud, or multiple violations face permanent inadmissibility that can only be overcome through extraordinary waivers that are rarely granted. Criminal penalties for illegal reentry after deportation are severe, ranging from 2 years imprisonment for basic illegal reentry to up to 20 years for aggravated felons who return without permission. The CBP Home voluntary departure program attempts to position itself as a middle option by eliminating the formal removal order and potentially preserving future immigration options while providing financial incentives, though participants must still address underlying unlawful presence bars through the standard waiver process. The key distinction remains that voluntary departure, when completed properly, does not carry the automatic and severe reentry restrictions that formal removal orders impose, making it the preferred option for individuals without criminal issues who wish to maintain any possibility of future legal immigration.

Immigration Court System and Case Backlog in the US 2024-2025

Court Metric Data Timeframe Context
Total Pending Cases 4+ million Q4 2024 All immigration courts
Pending Asylum Cases 1.5 million Q4 2024 Asylum-specific backlog
Immigration Decisions Issued (FY 2024) 666,177 Full FY 2024 All decision types
Removal Orders Issued Plurality of decisions FY 2024 Most common outcome
Average Wait Time for Hearing Multiple years Varies by location Non-detained cases
Expedited Removal (No Court) Expanded use 2025 Under 2 years in US
Board of Immigration Appeals Cases 1+ million pending Q4 2024 Appellate backlog

Data Source: Executive Office for Immigration Review, NPR Analysis, Department of Justice Immigration Statistics

The immigration court system faces unprecedented case backlogs that fundamentally shape enforcement outcomes and wait times. As of the fourth quarter of 2024, over 4 million cases remained pending before immigration judges nationwide, including 1.5 million asylum cases specifically. This massive backlog means that individuals in removal proceedings who are not detained typically wait multiple years before receiving a hearing date, during which time they often obtain work authorization and establish significant community ties. In Fiscal Year 2024, immigration courts issued 666,177 initial case decisions, with removal orders representing the plurality of outcomes, yet this decision rate failed to keep pace with new case filings, causing the backlog to continue growing.

The Board of Immigration Appeals, which handles appeals from immigration judge decisions, maintained its own backlog exceeding 1 million pending cases as of late 2024. Cases that reach the BIA can take additional years to resolve, and some proceed further to federal circuit courts and potentially the Supreme Court, though such appeals are rare. To bypass this lengthy court process, the Trump administration expanded use of expedited removal procedures that allow deportation of individuals who have been in the United States for less than two years without court hearings, as well as invoking the Alien Enemies Act for certain categories of individuals, though this latter approach faces intense legal scrutiny. The voluntary departure mechanism, whether traditional or through the CBP Home program, offers an alternative pathway that avoids the court system entirely, though it requires individuals to waive their rights to present defenses against removal. The tension between aggressive enforcement goals and severe court backlogs creates a practical limit on the pace of formal deportations, making voluntary departure programs attractive from an operational efficiency perspective regardless of their actual participation rates.

Economic and Workforce Impact of Self-Deportation in the US 2025

Economic Factor Impact Measurement Data Source/Estimate
Undocumented Worker Contribution to Workforce Significant sectors affected Construction, agriculture, hospitality
Estimated Tax Contributions (Undocumented) Billions annually IRS, Social Security Administration
Construction Industry Impact Workforce disruption reported Hispanic Construction Council
Social Security Contributions (Unclaimed) $5.7 billion annually (historical) Social Security estimates
Medicare Contributions Billions in contributions Medicare Trust Fund analysis
Projected Deportation Program Costs $965 billion over 10 years Cato Institute Analysis (HR 1)
GDP Impact (Mass Deportation Scenario) Potentially significant reduction Economic policy research

Data Source: Economic Policy Research, Government Agency Reports, Industry Association Statements

The economic implications of large-scale self-deportation and formal removal programs extend far beyond immediate enforcement costs. Undocumented workers contribute substantially to the U.S. economy through labor force participation, tax payments including payroll taxes that fund Social Security and Medicare, and consumer spending. Historical estimates suggest undocumented immigrants contribute approximately $5.7 billion annually to Social Security and significant amounts to Medicare through payroll deductions, despite many being ineligible to claim benefits. Industries including construction, agriculture, hospitality, and food processing rely heavily on immigrant labor, with industry representatives warning that enforcement operations are causing workforce disruptions and labor shortages.

The Hispanic Construction Council specifically noted in 2025 that immigration enforcement was causing “pain in the workforce,” affecting companies’ ability to complete projects and maintain operations. Economic analysis from institutions like the Cato Institute estimated that implementing comprehensive deportation programs could cost nearly $1 trillion over ten years when accounting for both enforcement expenses and lost economic productivity from removing workers who would have contributed more in taxes than they received in benefits. The Congressional Budget Office previously found that the 8.7 million increase in unauthorized immigrants during the Biden administration would reduce the federal deficit by $897 billion over ten years through their net positive fiscal contributions. Conversely, removing equivalent numbers would reverse these gains. While DHS emphasizes the $17,121 per-person deportation costs, broader economic analyses suggest the true fiscal impact includes lost tax revenue, reduced economic activity, and disrupted supply chains in critical industries, making the total economic cost substantially higher than direct enforcement expenses alone.

CBP Home Mobile App Features and Eligibility in the US 2025

Program Component Details Requirements/Conditions
Eligibility Non-criminal aliens in US without status Criminal history may disqualify
Registration Process Simple questionnaire via mobile app Takes minutes to complete
Personal Information Required Minimal data collection No A-Number required
Photo Verification Clear face photo required Sufficient lighting, face only
Travel Assistance Arranging travel for families Government coordination available
Departure Timeline Estimated 21 days after approval For those requesting assistance
Family Registration Co-travelers must register separately Including minors
Pending Court Cases Can still participate DHS files dismissal motion
De-prioritization Period Protection from ICE enforcement While showing “meaningful strides”

Data Source: CBP Home Official Website, DHS Program Guidelines

The CBP Home mobile application was designed with a streamlined user interface to minimize barriers to participation in the voluntary departure program. Eligibility extends to all non-criminal individuals present in the United States without legal status, with the program emphasizing that those with pending immigration court cases can still participate, as DHS will file motions to dismiss their proceedings. The registration process requires completing a brief questionnaire taking only minutes, with a privacy-conscious design that does not require individuals to provide their Alien Registration Numbers (A-Numbers) or other detailed personal identifiers that might deter participation due to fear of immediate enforcement action.

Photo verification requirements mandate that applicants submit clear facial photographs with sufficient lighting showing only their face, which the system uses to confirm identity upon departure. Individuals can register family members as co-travelers, though each person, including minors, must be separately registered within the app to receive program benefits. For those requesting travel assistance, the program promises coordination within an estimated 21 days of approval, though participants must provide accurate contact information and remain responsive to government outreach. The program offers de-prioritization for ICE enforcement actions while participants demonstrate “meaningful strides” toward departure, though specific definitions and documentation requirements for this protection remain unpublished. Pending immigration court cases do not disqualify participation, with DHS committing to file dismissal motions, though the program cautions that participants should consult immigration attorneys before indicating intent to depart, as this effectively waives rights to present defenses against removal. The $3,000 holiday incentive through December 31, 2025, represents a tripling of the original $1,000 exit bonus, paid after confirmation of arrival in the destination country through various disbursement methods that do not require participants to have bank accounts.

Alternatives to Detention and Monitoring Programs in the US 2024-2025

Program Type Technology/Method Participants (FY 2024) Purpose
Alternatives to Detention (ATD) Comprehensive monitoring program 179,000+ participants Case management for non-detained
Facial Matching Technology Smartphone app or issued device Significant portion Compliance reporting
GPS Monitoring Satellite tracking Significant portion Location compliance
Telephonic Reporting Voice verification check-ins Significant portion Regular reporting requirement
Wrist-Worn Devices GPS + facial matching + virtual management 50 devices (Denver pilot) Experimental deployment
Case Management Services Non-technology support Subset of ATD participants Humanitarian factors
Non-Detained Docket Total Various supervision levels 7.6 million cases Includes all pending cases

Data Source: ICE Annual Report FY 2024, ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations Statistics

The Alternatives to Detention (ATD) program represents ICE’s effort to manage the massive non-detained docket of 7.6 million pending cases without requiring physical detention for all individuals in removal proceedings. As of the end of Fiscal Year 2024, more than 179,000 participants were enrolled in the Intensive Supervision Appearance Program (ISAP), which uses technology-based monitoring combined with case management services to track compliance with immigration proceedings. The program employs multiple monitoring technologies, with participants assigned supervision levels based on criminal history, compliance history, community ties, caregiver responsibilities, and humanitarian factors.

Facial matching technology allows participants to report compliance through a mobile app installed on their personal smartphones or on government-issued devices, requiring regular photo submissions compared against enrollment biometrics. GPS monitoring uses satellite tracking to ensure participants comply with geographic restrictions and report to scheduled appointments. Telephonic reporting requires participants to make regular phone calls that are verified against voiceprints established during enrollment. The newest technology, wrist-worn devices, combines GPS tracking, facial matching, and virtual case management in a single unit, though as of FY 2024 ICE had deployed only 50 such devices in a limited pilot program in the Denver area. While ATD programs provide a cost-effective alternative to detention, with per-day costs substantially lower than the $165 for adult detention or $296 for family detention, the program’s effectiveness depends on participant compliance. The voluntary departure mechanism through CBP Home offers an exit pathway for ATD participants who prefer to leave rather than continue years-long immigration proceedings, though participation numbers suggest relatively few have chosen this option despite the financial incentives offered.

Disclaimer: This research report is compiled from publicly available sources. While reasonable efforts have been made to ensure accuracy, no representation or warranty, express or implied, is given as to the completeness or reliability of the information. We accept no liability for any errors, omissions, losses, or damages of any kind arising from the use of this report.